I didn’t know what this show was about when I first started to watch it, I just watched the previews and didn’t read the description. I thought it looked cool.
It _does_ look cool. In fact, it looks amazing. The cinematography and sets are incredible. They do a very good job portraying how the city would have looked in Victorian London (from what I know of Victorian London).
The cast is diverse and they’re all actually pretty decent actors. Their situation and they’re characters are a bit at odds.
The problem is that you really, really, really have to suspend your disbelief if you’re going to go for the premise. I can see Sir Arthur Conan Doyle fans frothing at the mouth in rage at this adaptation. Okay, rage is a strong word. They would not be amused?
The Irregulars are too well groomed (oh, yes, there’s the well placed grime on their faces), to well read—I doubt very much that one of them, in reality, would be able to read, much less all of them. Leo sticks out like a sore thumb, even with abovementioned grime. His blue coat is always spotless. The fact that he knows everything could be attributed to his being, as he himself says, well-read. I imagine he would probably have led as pretty sequestered life considering his health condition.
So I think to enjoy the show you just have to let all that go. Stick the show into a completely alternative universe where Victorian London looks like Victorian London but is just a little too clean.
The stories so far (I’m into the fourth one) are entertaining enough. You still have to suspend your disbelief, though. They live in what looks cool, but if you really start to think about it, are they living in the sewers? It must reek to high heaven, not to mention the health risks. Unless it’s the Thames, which, well, pretty much the same thing.
There are positive aspects of the show. The group has created their own little family and band together whereas if they were on their own, especially Jessica, they would be much worse off. It sort of reminds me a little of Shadowhunters, except with better sets and atmosphere. I think it would appeal to the same people who watched Shadowhunters.
I don’t think I can really rate it—I think you’re either going to like it or not like it. I think it ranks with shows like Forever Knight and other shows of that era of Canadian TV which are charming in their campiness. The Irregulars takes itself more seriously, and that doesn’t come off as well.
There are a lot of things to look at, and what does Bea’s necklace really look like? It looks cool. But be prepared for a Dr. Watson unlike any other. He’s quite…the personality.
You must be logged in to post a comment.